Chapter 2: The First Dance**
Chapter 2: The First Dance
The silence in the booth stretched for a full three seconds, taut and electric. Jason’s hand remained on Carrie’s thigh, a bold, immovable weight. Rick watched, his heart hammering a frantic rhythm against his ribs. He saw the tiny, almost imperceptible tremor in Carrie’s leg, the way her eyes, wide and luminous, were locked on Jason’s. She wasn’t pulling away. She wasn't slapping him. She was frozen, a deer caught not in headlights, but in the mesmerizing glow of a long-dormant desire.
Just as the tension threatened to snap, Jason moved. With the same casual grace he’d used to place it there, he lifted his hand, letting his fingers trail lightly against the denim of her shorts as he reached for his drink. The motion was so smooth it could have been an afterthought, but the charge it left behind was undeniable. The air in the booth was different now, thick with unspoken permissions and simmering heat.
As if on cue, the bar’s sound system shifted from moody indie rock to a track with a deeper, more insistent pulse. A low, thumping club beat that vibrated through the floorboards and up into Rick’s very bones.
Jason leaned back, a picture of relaxed confidence, though his eyes never left Carrie. “I love this song,” he said, his voice a low, intimate rumble. He gestured with his head toward the small, empty space near the jukebox that served as Marty’s dance floor. “Professor, would you do me the honor?”
Carrie’s gaze snapped from Jason to Rick, a silent, desperate question in their depths. Her expression was a chaotic battlefield of temptation and marital duty. It was the look of a woman standing on a precipice, needing either a hand to pull her back or a gentle push over the edge.
Rick knew which one he wanted to give. This was the moment of truth. He could play the jealous husband, reclaim his wife, and go home to their quiet, comfortable silence. Or he could pour gasoline on the spark he’d so carefully nurtured.
He gave her a slow, easy smile, the kind he knew would disarm her. “Go on, honey,” he said, his voice betraying none of the roaring excitement in his veins. “Don’t let me be the boring old husband keeping you glued to the seat. Have some fun. I’ll hold down the fort.”
Permission granted. The relief that washed over Carrie’s face was so profound it was almost comical. She gave Rick a quick, grateful smile before turning back to Jason. The telltale bite to her lower lip was back, but this time it was less about nerves and more about pure, unadulterated anticipation.
“Okay,” she breathed, her voice a little unsteady. “But I’m warning you, it’s been a while.”
“I’m a great teacher,” Jason promised, his grin turning predatory as he slid out of the booth and offered her his hand.
Rick leaned back, nursing his whiskey, a king watching the first moves of a game on a board of his own design. He watched Jason lead his wife—his Carrie—to the dance floor. The space was small, intimate, lit only by the garish, colorful glow of the jukebox. For a moment, they kept a respectable distance. Jason was a fluid, confident dancer, and Carrie, after a few stiff moments, began to relax. The brilliant professor, the respected wife, started to melt away, replaced by someone Rick hadn't seen in years. The girl he’d fallen in love with, the one with the wild streak she tried so hard to keep hidden.
The thumping beat seemed to be a physical force, pulling them together. Jason’s hands, which had started on her waist, slid lower, settling in the dip of her lower back, his thumbs pressing into the sensitive skin just above her shorts. He drew her in until their bodies were flush, moving as one. Carrie didn’t resist. Instead, she leaned into it, her head falling back slightly, her eyes half-closed in surrender.
Rick’s grip on his glass tightened. A primal mix of jealousy and white-hot arousal flooded his system. This was more provocative, more real than any fantasy he had ever dared to conjure. He could see Jason whispering something in her ear, his lips brushing against her skin. Carrie laughed, a sound that was lost to the music but that Rick could see in the joyful arch of her throat.
He was completely entranced, his world narrowed to the sight of his wife in another man’s arms. He saw the way the purple of her top seemed to deepen in the dim light, the way the muscles in her long legs tensed as she moved against Jason. This was the window he’d wanted to open, and the view was intoxicating. He was watching his wife being desired, being claimed, even if just for a single dance.
The song was reaching its crescendo, the beat pounding like a shared heartbeat. Jason spun Carrie out and then pulled her back in, her back now pressed firmly against his chest. His arms wrapped around her, one hand splayed possessively across her stomach, the other tracing the line of her collarbone. He leaned down, his face disappearing into the cascade of her dark hair.
Rick held his breath. He knew what was coming. He willed it to happen.
Jason’s lips emerged, pressing a slow, deliberate kiss to the pulse point on Carrie’s neck. It wasn't chaste. It was a mark. A brand. And Carrie… Carrie did nothing. She didn’t flinch, didn’t pull away. Instead, her head tilted to the side, giving him better access. Her body went pliant in his arms, a silent, willing surrender.
A wave of heat crashed over Rick, so intense it made him dizzy. It was a fulfillment so complete it felt like a physical blow. The sight of it—the ultimate taboo, his wife willingly receiving another man’s touch, another man’s kiss—was the most profoundly erotic thing he had ever witnessed. His fantasy was real. It was happening. Right there, ten feet away from him.
He was lost in the voyeuristic haze, his reality reduced to the pulsing music and the illicit scene on the dance floor. He was so consumed that he didn’t hear the soft footsteps approaching the booth. He didn’t notice the new presence beside him until a voice, sweet as honey but sharp as glass, cut through his trance.
“He’s good, isn’t he?”
Rick’s head snapped to the side.
Standing there, a faint, knowing smile playing on her lips, was a young woman. She was beautiful, with a curvy, pear-shaped figure and bright, intelligent eyes that seemed to see right through him. She looked from Rick, to the entwined figures on the dance floor, and then back to Rick again.
His mind scrambled to place her. The pretty face, the mention of clinicals, the confidence…
His blood ran cold.
“My boyfriend, Jason,” the young woman clarified, her smile widening as she slid gracefully into the booth opposite him. “He always did have a thing for his teachers.”
Rick’s voyeuristic trance shattered into a million pieces. His perfect, controlled fantasy hadn’t just been interrupted; it had been invaded. Standing before him was the girlfriend, Emily, and her playful, perceptive gaze held not a single ounce of shock or anger. It held something far more terrifying: understanding.
Characters

Carrie Stine

Emily

Jason
